Advertisements

How Do You Solve A Problem Like Guardians?

I want to love Bendis’ Guardians of the Galaxy series. I really do. I generally enjoy Bendis’ writing and hell after the movie, who isn’t a fan of the Guardians? You may remember a while back I read the first three issues to familiarize myself with the characters. The story was good enough, but it didn’t leave me dying to read more. After I finished it my curiosity was quenched. I’ve followed the series on and off, but most recently was able to re-read everything and catch up to the latest issue (which at the time of this writing is #21).

guardians2

Brian Michael Bendis is known for his decompression style, where a storyline that could have been written in an issue or two (and most certainly would have back in the day) will end up being stretched out over four or five. I use to hate when people would say they don’t like reading his books because “nothing ever happens”.  It wasn’t until this reading of Guardians as well as the current Last Will & Testament of Charles Xavier storyline that’s going on over in Uncanny X-Men that finally made me agree.

Maybe I was kind of spoiled because retrospectively a lot did happen in those first 3 issues of Guardians. By the time we get to the third arc where the entire team is captured I was upset by how circumstantially it seemed that Star Lord was rescued. The rest of the team followed in suit and what took 3 or 4 issues to build towards was resolved in about 5 pages. Surely, Bendis is a better writer than that?

CaptainMarvelSavesPeterQuill

This series has also suffered from crossovers. Issues #8 and 9 were Infinity Tie-Ins, #11-13 were part of the Trial Of Jean Grey that also ran through Bendis’ X-Men books and #18-20 were part of Original Sin. Nearly half of the current issue output has been a victim of crossovers. Now if that wasn’t bad enough, Guardians #24 is part of the Black Vortex a new crossover with the X-Men (again). Recently, Bendis has also brought his All New X-Men book into the Ultimate Universe for a crossover with Ultimate Spider-Man for the last 4 or 5 issues which is fine but it looks like they are getting one issue to go back to normal before jumping into this Black Vortex crossover. That’s insane! I get the idea of Bendis wanting to have the titles he’s writing cross paths, how could that not be fun for him? The fact of the matter is that this is incredibly fatiguing to the average reader.

I do like that Bendis isn’t keeping the team lineup static by bringing in both Captain Marvel as well as Agent Venom, both seem to be interesting and natural fits for the team. The problem though is that we’ve got to spend virtually no time with them. Agent Venom we see a little bit of since he joined first and is thankfully the focus of the current storyline (#21-23) but Captain Marvel joined the team and the next 3 issues were the Original Sin tie-ins that specifically dealt with a period of time prior to the start of the series. Even Anegla who joined the team when the book was in the single digits has barely had any screen time. It’s downright maddening.

Ylom6bQl

After catching up, I decided to dive into the Abnett & Lanning’s 2008 Guardians series and reading the first trade (issues #1-12) I was extremely satisfied with it. It’s just that Guardians is such a fun property and Bendis is so capable, it’s sad to see it not panning out. I should also add that I don’t think the series is bad, it’s just a bit boring and lacking something. I read the first three issues of the Star-Lord series as well and I couldn’t wait to give up on that book. I don’t understand how you wouldn’t be giving these characters the best of the best , A+, top quality production teams when you have a movie that was an insanely successful box office smash. I haven’t read the Rocket Raccoon series, but soon there will be a Gamora title, Angela and a Guardians team up book. I know these will be successful at first coasting on the film’s momentum, but if they don’t step things up these are going to fade into oblivion.

All images and characters depicted are copyright of their respective owners. Please click on the “About Us” tab for our takedown policy.

Advertisements

About Biff Tannen

Film Noir, Pulp, Comic Books and Hitchcock.

Posted on December 4, 2014, in COMICS!, Rants and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 4 Comments.

  1. I agree with you completely except that Bendis is capable. Its 20+ issues in and so far it has been a chore to read nearly every single issue. Every fan of Nova and the Guardians have been waiting to see what happened in the cancerverse and then it was drawn out over $12 of comics to see that Nova dies. Guardians 3000 has proved to be a vastly superior book. Check it out. I love the Abnett/Lanning stuff and this has been a disappointing run so far for Bendis. I hope he gets overwhelmed and leaves Guardians.

  2. Well, I gotta disagree. I really like the new series and think that the Original Sin stuff is without a doubt central to the GoTG continuity from the last series, in fact it’s the missing piece of the puzzle that was the current GoTG series in my opinion. Also, the X-Men crossover became a really big deal for the overall storyline that Bendis has built from issue 1 and again parts of it are remnants from other stories like War of Kings and Infinity. I read the entire modern Guardians in roughly 3 months, and will agree that the new series isn’t as good as the Abnett/Lanning one, but it’s not awful either. One thing is that it’s not the movie, which I’m fine with to be honest.

    • I certainly don’t think Bendis’ take on the team is awful by any stretch of the imagination, I just think with his pedigree it could be better. I like it, I but I don’t love it. As for the crossovers, it’s not the content of them that really bothers me. It’s both the frequency in which it seems to be happening as well as the fact that with each one I feel like it derails the main story that Bendis is (slowly) building towards.

  1. Pingback: All New, All Different Marvel Mini Reviews (Part 1) | "The Brotherhood of Evil Geeks"

Share your Evil Geek thoughts...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: